The information below comes from the statement of deficiencies compiled by health inspectors and provided to AHCJ by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. It does not include the steps the hospital plans to take to fix the problem, known as a plan of correction. For that information, you should contact the hospital, your state health department or CMS. Accessing the document may require you to file a Freedom of Information Request. Information on doing so is available here.
|SAINT ALPHONSUS REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER||1055 NORTH CURTIS ROAD BOISE, ID 83706||April 10, 2018|
|VIOLATION: COMPLIANCE WITH 489.24||Tag No: A2400|
|Based on record review, review of hospital policies, patient/family interview, and staff interview, it was determined the hospital failed to ensure emergency services were provided in compliance with 42 CFR Part 489.24. This resulted in the lack of an appropriate MSE for 1 of 17 minor patients (#1). Findings include:
Refer to A2406 as it relates to the failure of the hospital to provide an appropriate medical screening examination.
|VIOLATION: MEDICAL SCREENING EXAM||Tag No: A2406|
|**NOTE- TERMS IN BRACKETS HAVE BEEN EDITED TO PROTECT CONFIDENTIALITY**
Based on record review, policy review, patient/family interview, and staff interview, it was determined the hospital failed to ensure an MSE was provided to 1 of 17 ED patients (Patient #1) who were minors and whose records were reviewed. This had the potential to result in patients with undiagnosed emergency medical conditions. Findings include:
The policy "Consent for Medical Treatment" was approved on 11/15/17. It stated, "Who May Give Informed Consent?...a person of 14 years of age or older may provide Informed Consent to treatment for mental illness."
Another hospital policy "Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA) Compliance," approved 5/12/17, stated "Any individual who comes to Saint Alphonsus (the "Hospital") seeking an examination and treatment of a potential emergency medical condition will receive a screening examination to determine the existence of any emergency medical condition..."
These policies were not followed:
Patient #1 was a [AGE] year old female who presented to the ED at 9:29 PM on 2/23/18, for evaluation of her behavioral health status. Patient #1 was brought in by her parents following an encounter with police.
Patient #1's record included a triage note on 2/23/18 at 9:36 PM, signed by the triage RN. The triage note stated Patient #1's mother claimed the girl was a danger to others. The note further stated the girl was discharged 8 days ago from a behavioral health facility. The triage note also stated "Pt's mother and step father [are] extremely agitated after being told they have to stay with pt." The note stated the mother said, "I am not going to sit here and watch her be pampered."
The triage note included Patient #1's vital signs and allergies. There was no documentation of psychiatric, abuse, or social assessments. The note did not clarify how Patient #1 was a danger to others.
Patient #1's record documented her acuity as "Emergent," but did not include a complete triage or nursing assessment. There was no documentation an assessment was performed of Patient #1's psychiatric status. The record did not state if Patient #1 was a danger to herself or others.
The triage RN documented in her progress notes Patient #1's parents were becoming more upset and at 9:52 PM "Step father and mother increasingly agitated after being told they can't drop off pt and leave." From 9:36 PM to 9:52 PM, 16 minutes, there was no further documentation of assessment by the RN.
At 10:15 PM, the triage RN documented "Pt upset not wanting to leave with mother but resolved to go." Patient #1's record documented she had LWBS at 10:17 PM, 48 minutes after she presented to the ED for evaluation.
There was no documentation in Patient #1's record she was taken to an ED room for evaluation by a provider. There was no documentation of an MSE by a qualified person.
Patient #1's medical record included a "CONSENT TO MEDICAL CARE AND PATIENT SERVICES AGREEMENT" signed by her mother at 9:34 PM on 2/23/18.
Patient #1's medical record included an "INFORMED CONSENT TO REFUSE OFFERED SERVICES" form. The form was signed by a witness at 10:12 PM on 2/23/18, but there was no signature by Patient #1 or her parents.
During a phone interview beginning at 11:45 AM on 4/05/18, the Charge RN stated he was the charge nurse on the evening of 2/23/18, and was called over the radio to provide assistance in triage. He stated the triage RN informed him the parents of Patient #1 told her they "could not handle her anymore" and were told by police they "could drop her off and leave." The Charge RN stated Patient #1's father told him he wanted to "drop her off and go." He stated he told the parents he wanted to talk with the LCSW in the ED to verify they could do that. The Charge RN stated he spoke with the LCSW and she informed him the parents of Patient #1 could not leave her in the ED. He stated he went back to the triage area with the LCSW and she informed the parents if they wanted her evaluated they could not leave. The Charge RN stated he spoke with Patient #1 and asked her whether she was suicidal or wanted to hurt other people and she stated she did not. He stated Patient #1 also told him she did not know why she was there and she did not want to be in the ED. The Charge RN confirmed the conversations mentioned above were not documented in Patient #1's record.
During an interview via phone beginning at 4:15 PM on 4/05/18, the RN who triaged Patient #1 stated she called Patient #1 into the triage room and her parents did not initially come into the room with her. She stated she asked the parents to come into the triage room and when she asked Patient #1 why she was there, Patient #1 did not answer. The RN stated Patient #1's mother told her Patient #1 wanted to harm other family members and she wanted to "drop her off." She stated she informed Patient #1's mother she could not leave the patient there because she was a minor. The RN stated the father, or stepfather-she was unsure of the relationship-would come in the room and state something then step out again. The RN stated the mother left the triage room and she asked Patient #1 if she wanted to hurt her family and she stated "No."
The RN stated she went and got the Charge RN, and he spoke with Patient #1 and her mother. The RN stated the Charge RN informed Patient #1's parents they must be present for the patient to be evaluated. She stated after the parents of Patient #1 spoke with the Charge RN, another staff member informed her Patient #1 was out in the waiting room alone and her parents had left. The RN stated she informed Patient #1 not to leave the waiting room and she went to talk with the Charge RN. She stated the staff member came back in the ED to inform her Patient #1's parents had returned and Patient #1 did not want to leave with them. The RN stated Patient #1's mother told her "Let's go" but Patient #1 told the RN she did not want to go with them. The RN stated she told Patient #1 "This is your family, you have to go with them" and Patient #1 stated "Fine." The RN stated she was not aware at that time of the policy regarding minors 14 and older being able to consent for their own evaluation and treatment.
During a phone interview beginning at 11:45 AM on 4/09/18, Patient #1's mother stated she had a police officer come to her house. She stated the officer told her she could take Patient #1 to the ED and not have to stay with her. Patient #1's mother stated at the ED she was informed she had to stay with her daughter for her to be evaluated. Patient #1's mother stated she made it clear to staff that she did want Patient #1 evaluated and treated. She stated staff told her their policy was her daughter had to be 16 or older to stay without a parent or guardian.
The hospital failed to provide an MSE to Patient #1.